Pahankanuwa Sermon 042
Pahankanuwa Sermon #42
English Translation
Translated from Sinhala
Author: Ven. Katukurunde Nanananda Thero
(Pahankaį¹uwa Sinhala Audio Dhamma Sermon No.169)
Namo tassa bhagavato arahato sammÄsambuddhassa
(Homage to the Blessed One, the Worthy One, the Fully Self-Enlightened One)
Pali Stanza:
Ayaį¹ loko paro loko, jÄnatÄ suppakÄsito;
MÄrena sappattaį¹ appattaį¹ yaƱca maccunÄ.
Sabbaį¹ lokaį¹ abhiƱƱÄya, sambuddhena pajÄnatÄ;
Vivaį¹aį¹ amatadvÄraį¹, khemaį¹ nibbÄnapattiyÄ.
Chinnaį¹ pÄpimato sotaį¹, viddhastaį¹ vinÄlÄ«kataį¹;
PÄmojjabahulÄ hotha, khemaį¹ nibbÄnapattiyÄ.
From:
CūḷagopÄlaka Sutta, Majjhima NikÄya
Dear Listeners,
The Noble Eightfold Path, placed before the world by the Teacher of the Three Worlds, the Fully Self-Awakened One, on an Esala Full Moon Poya day like today, is the only transcendental path to cross over from this shore to the other shore, parting the fierce flood of this terrifying saį¹sÄra. It is the salvific path that leads to the further shore of NibbÄna, escaping the realm of MÄra and remaining beyond his grasp. Just as a skilled cowherd safely guides his herd of cattle across a river from this bank to the other during the rainy season, the Teacher of the Three Worlds, the Fully Self-Awakened One, revealed the Middle Path to lead worldly beings across the fierce flood of saį¹sÄra to the other shore.
In the CūḷagopÄlaka Sutta of the Majjhima NikÄya, the Buddha illustrated His peerless, supreme enlightenment through the simile of a cowherd. The three verses that come at the very end to culminate this Sutta discourse are what we have taken as our topic today. According to the Sutta, the background story is as follows: On one occasion, the Blessed One was staying among a group of monks on the banks of the River Ganges near the town of UkkÄcelÄ in the Vajjian country. As it appears to us, this was not due to some unusual problem or event. It may be that the Buddha wished to deliver a heart-touching sermon to the Sangha, drawing inspiration from a common sight frequently witnessed on the River Ganges. In any case, He began the discourse in this manner. In the Pali language, there is a word, bhÅ«tapubbaį¹. Its meaning is a true eventāindeed, such an event actually occurred. It begins with that word: "Monks, once upon a time, such an event occurred. What was it? A foolish cowherd of Magadha, in the last month of the rainy season, during the autumn, tried to drive his herd of cattle across the River Ganges to the Videhan country on the opposite bank, without properly examining this bank, without properly examining the further bank, and at a place that was not a ford (anotitithena)." As you merit-seeking devotees know, a ford is the shallowest place in a river, where it is easy to cross. He tried to cross his herd not at a proper ford, but at a non-ford. "But monks, that herd of cattle got caught in the current in the middle of the river and met with destruction." What was the reason? That cowherd of Magadha was unwise. Furthermore, before undertaking that task, he did not properly examine this bank, nor did he properly examine the further bank. And he tried to cross the cattle at a non-ford. That is why it was not successful. "In the same way, monks, if any ascetics and brahmins are unskilled regarding this world"āthe word used there is akusalÄā"unskilled regarding the next world, without comprehension, unskilled regarding the realm of MÄra, unskilled regarding what is not the realm of MÄra, unskilled regarding the region subject to death (Maccu); if anyone decides to place faith in such ascetics and brahmins, and decides to listen to them, that will lead to their harm, suffering (dukkha), and misfortune for a long time." Thus, the Buddha declared.
In line with that simile, the Buddha next presents another factual event: "Monks, such an event also occurred. A skilled, wise cowherd of Magadha, in the very same way, in the last month of the rainy season during autumn, properly examined this bank of the river, properly examined the further bank, and crossed his herd of cattle at the proper ford." The Buddha beautifully describes the manner in which they were crossed. First, that cowherd took the bulls who were the leaders of the herd (gopitaro gopariį¹ÄyakÄ), the chief cattle, and they cut across the river's current, went forward, and crossed over safely. Secondly, the strong cattle and cows of the herd similarly cut across the river's currents, went forward, and crossed over. Thirdly, the grown heifers and young bulls likewise cut across the river's current, went forward, and crossed over safely. Fourthly, the weak calves of the herd were also taken across, cutting through the current, going forward, and crossing over safely. Then the Buddha declares something further, something very special: "Monks, such a thing also occurred on that occasion. There was a newborn calf in that herd, born that very day, who, being urged on by its mother's lowing"āthere is a unique phrase mentioned there, which scholars interpret in various ways: mÄtugoravena vuyhamÄno. As you merit-seeking devotees know, after a cow gives birth to a calf, she makes a special protective sound, like "hum, hum." Urging the calf forward with that sound, or searching for it when lost; encouraged by that lowing sound of the mother, the newborn calf also went forward safely through the water parted by its motherās chest and crossed over.
Then the Buddha explains according to that simile: "What was the reason? That cowherd was wise. He properly examined this bank, he properly examined the further bank, and he crossed the cattle at the proper ford. That is why it was successful. In the same way, monks, if any ascetics and brahmins are skilled regarding this world, skilled regarding the next world, skilled regarding the realm of MÄra, skilled regarding what is not the realm of MÄra, skilled regarding the region subject to death, and skilled regarding the region free from death; if anyone thinks it fit to listen to such ascetics and brahmins and thinks it fit to place faith in them, that will lead to their benefit and happiness for a long time." Having declared this, using the actions of the skilled cowherd as a simile, the Buddha next explains the corresponding reality regarding the individuals in this Dispensation (SÄsana): "Just as, monks, that cowherd first crossed the bulls, the leaders of the herd, so too, monks, the Arahants in this Dispensation, having severed the ten fetters (saį¹yojana) that bind one to saį¹sÄra, and having destroyed the taints (Äsava)"āmany other terms describing Arahants are mentioned thereā"the Arahants in this Dispensation cross over safely to the further shore of NibbÄna, having cut all ten fetters." Thus, that is the simile for them. The Arahants, having destroyed all defilements and become pure, cross over safely.
Secondly, showing the second point, just as the strong cattle and cows of the herd crossed over safely next, in this Dispensation, what is spoken of nextāas you merit-seeking devotees knowāis about the Non-Returner (AnÄgÄmÄ«) noble individuals. Now let us define the ten fetters (saį¹yojana) for those who do not know. Fetters are described as the bonds that tie one to saį¹sÄra. They are: dogma of self-illusion (sakkÄya-diį¹į¹hi), skeptical doubt (vicikicchÄ), adherence to rules and rituals (sÄ«labbata-parÄmÄsa), sensual lust (kÄmarÄga), ill-will (paį¹igha), craving for fine-material existence (rÅ«parÄga), craving for immaterial existence (arÅ«parÄga), conceit (mÄna), restlessness (uddhacca), and ignorance (avijjÄ). These ten are known in the Dhamma as the ten fetters (saį¹yojana). The ten fetters are divided in the Dhamma, dear devotees, into the lower fetters (oramabhÄgiya) and the higher fetters (uddhambhÄgiya). The lower fetters belong to this sideāwhen we look from this side, the five fetters on this side. The higher fetters belong to the upper side. So, regarding the Non-Returner (AnÄgÄmÄ«), it is mentioned that they have severed those five lower fetters, and as you may have heard, they are reborn spontaneously (opapÄtika), without parents, in the Pure Abodes (SuddhÄvÄsa). They take birth in the Pure Abodes of the Brahma world: Aviha, Atappa, Sudassa, SudassÄ«, and Akaniį¹į¹ha. Moreover, the meaning of the word AnÄgÄmÄ« is "one who does not return here." The Non-Returner does not come back to this world. Another phrase is used in the Dhamma for this: anÄvattidhammo tasmÄ lokÄānot returning from that world. They do not turn back from the Brahma world. The Non-Returner who has attained that state is compared to the second category of cattle. Thus, regarding those individuals, the Buddha declares that while the Arahants have crossed over, these individuals "will cross over." It is stated in the future tense; they will definitely cross over, with certainty. The Buddha affirms this decisively regarding Non-Returners. Now you can understand that second point.
Thirdly, just as the grown heifers and young bulls were crossed over, in this Dispensation, we next have the Once-Returner (SakadÄgÄmÄ«). You have probably heard the meaning of the word SakadÄgÄmÄ«: one who comes to this world only once more. Regarding Once-Returners (SakadÄgÄmÄ«), this is how it is described in the Dhamma, and in this Sutta too, it is said that they have severed the first three fettersāthe dogma of self-illusion (sakkÄya-diį¹į¹hi), skeptical doubt (vicikicchÄ), and adherence to rules and rituals (sÄ«labbata-parÄmÄsa)āand in addition, they have thinned out the defilements of lust, hatred, and delusion. So, they have severed three fetters and thinned out lust, hatred, and delusion. To cut through the river's current, the Buddha here compares it to cutting through MÄraās stream: MÄrassa sotaį¹ chetvÄāhaving cut MÄraās stream. MÄraās stream is craving (taį¹hÄ). Cutting through the stream of craving (taį¹hÄ), this third group will also cross over. They will definitely go. It is something that happens in the future. They return only once, but they will definitely realize NibbÄna. That is the third category.
In the fourth category are the weak calves. That simile is shown regarding the Stream-Enterer (SotÄpanna). Regarding those who have severed only the first three fettersādogma of self-illusion (sakkÄya-diį¹į¹hi), skeptical doubt (vicikicchÄ), and adherence to rules and rituals (sÄ«labbata-parÄmÄsa)āthe Buddha often mentions sambodhiparÄyaį¹o (bound for awakening) and avinipÄtadhammo (not subject to ruin/rebirth in lower worlds). They do not go to the hells anymore; they do not go to states of misery. Special things are mentioned about the Stream-Enterer too. Just as Arahants are spoken of from that end, if we look from this end at the level of ordinary people, the Stream-Enterer is indeed a noble being. Yet, here they are compared to the weak calves. Why is that? "Calves" because they have severed only three out of the ten fetters. This is not said to disparage them, but this much is certain. It is mentioned in other places regarding themāeven if not in this Sutta, you merit-seeking devotees have heard itāthe Stream-Enterer is described as sattakkhattuparama, meaning they take birth at most seven more times. Within seven lifetimes, they will somehow bring an end to saį¹sÄric suffering (dukkha). There are the words niyato sambodhiparÄyaį¹oādestined with certainty for awakening. "Awakening" (sambodhi) means NibbÄna, or Arhatship. They will attain Arhatship. That reassurance exists for the Stream-Enterer too. Moreover, avinipÄtadhammo means they are free from rebirth in the hells and states of misery. Thus, they are compared to the weak calves.
Now comes a deeper part. For the next, fifth category, the Buddha shows words that most of you have probably not heard: "Just as, monks, that newborn calf, born that very day, crossed over urged by its mother's lowing and with her assistance, so too in this Dispensation there are two groups of individuals: those called DhammÄnusÄrÄ« (Dhamma-followers) and SaddhÄnusÄrÄ« (Faith-followers)." These two groups are even below the level of Stream-Entry (SotÄpanna). Yet the Buddha declares even of these two groups that, like the newborn calf, these two tender ones will also definitely cross over. This is a source of great consolation in this Dispensation. It shows that it does not end only with the Stream-Enterer; there is still room for others. This means that the Buddha has revealed a Middle Path by which even those newborn calves can cut through MÄra's stream and cross over. So, those two categories of individuals, the DhammÄnusÄrÄ« and SaddhÄnusÄrÄ«, cross over in that manner. We shall speak of them to you devotees in due course. Let us first finish this story. In brief, this is all that is said here. Compared to that calf are the noble individuals in this Dispensation named DhammÄnusÄrÄ« and SaddhÄnusÄrÄ«. Those two groups, who are mentioned in places describing virtuous people (sappurisa), will also, just like the others, definitely cross over someday.
Having said this, the Buddha explains the reason for it by making a declaration akin to a lion's roar: "Monks, why is this so? Because, monks, I am skilled regarding this world"āthe word used is kusalo (skilled)ā"I am skilled regarding the next world, skilled regarding the realm of MÄra, skilled regarding the region subject to death, and skilled regarding the region free from death. Therefore, monks, if any deem it fit to listen to me, and deem it fit to arouse faith in me, that will lead to their benefit and happiness for a long time." Having declared this, He uttered the three verses we have taken as our topic, which culminate that discourse.
Ayaį¹ loko paro loko jÄnatÄ suppakÄsito... The meaning of this verse is: This world and the world beyond have been well declared by the One with deep understandingāit is understood here that it refers to the Buddha, the Fully Self-Awakened One. Next, it says: yaƱca mÄrena sampattaį¹āthat which can be reached by MÄra; appattaį¹ yaƱca maccunÄāand that which cannot be reached by Death. Both of these have been declared by the Fully Self-Awakened One.
Sabbaį¹ lokaį¹ abhiƱƱÄya sambuddhena pajÄnatÄ, vivaį¹aį¹ amatadvÄraį¹ khemaį¹ nibbÄnapattiyÄ. Having known the entire world through direct knowledge (abhiƱƱÄ), with supreme wisdom, the Fully Self-Awakened One who understands, has opened the door to the Deathless (amatadvÄraį¹), the secure door to the Deathless, for the attainment of NibbÄna.
The next verse says: Chinnaį¹ pÄpimato sotaį¹ viddhastaį¹ vinalÄ«kataį¹, pÄmojjabahulÄ hotha, khemaį¹... bhikkhavo. That victory is then declared by the Buddha in the next verse: chinnaį¹ pÄpimato sotaį¹āthe stream of the Evil One, that stream which was mentioned, has been severed. viddhastaį¹āit has been destroyed; vinalÄ«kataį¹āthe pride of MÄra has been rendered useless. Therefore, pÄmojjabahulÄ hothaābe full of joy and happiness, O monks. "Seek the secure..." Here, it means to aspire for NibbÄna. So, we have discussed almost the entirety of that Sutta.
Now, what remains is for us to say something by way of commentary. Especially from the points mentioned in the Sutta, through the comparison of the simile and the reality, you merit-seeking devotees can understand this. Even though more details are not given, everyone has heard at this point the descriptions of the Stream-Enterer, Once-Returner, Non-Returner, and Arahant. Something unique mentioned here, however, is the DhammÄnusÄrÄ« and SaddhÄnusÄrÄ«. It is on this that we will make a special commentary. These two groups are only briefly mentioned in this Sutta. However, in certain places in several Suttas, the Buddha describes these two generally unrevealed/uncommon individuals in this manner. Specifically, in the AlagaddÅ«pama Sutta, it is mentioned that the DhammÄnusÄrÄ« and SaddhÄnusÄrÄ« are indeed destined with certainty for awakening (sambodhiparÄyaį¹o), bound for NibbÄna or Arhatship in this Dispensation.
Their qualifications are mentioned next in the KÄ«į¹Ägiri Sutta of the Majjhima NikÄya, where they are presented more clearly at the end of a list of seven types of individuals. Regarding the DhammÄnusÄrÄ« individual, it is mentioned in the KÄ«į¹Ägiri Sutta as follows: that DhammÄnusÄrÄ« individual has, to a certain extent, reflected upon and scrutinized with wisdom the teachings declared by the TathÄgata, and has gained a conviction in them. The Pali phrase used for this is also deep: mattaso nijjhÄnaį¹ khamanti. To a certain degree or measure, nijjhÄnaį¹ khamanti means we can say they have become convinced. Having thought and reflected, they have reached a certain conclusion: "Ah, this is indeed so." That is on their part. Next, the special thing is that within this DhammÄnusÄrÄ« individual, there are establishedāas you merit-seeking devotees have also heard among the thirty-seven aids to awakeningāthe five spiritual faculties (indriya): faith (saddhÄ), energy (viriya), mindfulness (sati), concentration (samÄdhi), and wisdom (paƱƱÄ). Thus, the five spiritual facultiesāthe faculty of faith (saddhindriya), energy (viriyindriya), mindfulness (satindriya), concentration (samÄhindriya), and wisdom (paƱƱindriya)āare established within this DhammÄnusÄrÄ« individual. That is why an ordinary worldling (puthujjana) does not possess them. Even if they think they do, in no way whatsoeverāsabbena sabbaį¹ sabbathÄ sabbaį¹āare these five faculties established in an ordinary worldling. Faith may be present, and the other qualities may be present, but they have not reached the status of a spiritual faculty (indriya). Thus, at the very least, that status has been attained by this DhammÄnusÄrÄ« individual. So, why is the word DhammÄnusÄrÄ« used? There is a deep meaning for the reason here. Among those five faculties, some have developed a particular one strongly in saį¹sÄra. For some, the faculty of faith (saddhindriya) is strong. Now, in this DhammÄnusÄrÄ« individual, the faculty of wisdom (paƱƱindriya) is strong. While all five are established, the faculty of wisdom is particularly strong, enabling them to proceed with their practice. Further details are mentioned about this. If we speak systematically, that is what is described in the KÄ«į¹Ägiri Sutta.
Similarly, next, regarding the SaddhÄnusÄrÄ« individual, they differ from the DhammÄnusÄrÄ« in that while the former walks this path in accordance with the Dhamma, the SaddhÄnusÄrÄ« individual crosses over in accordance with faith, utilizing faith as their support. Therefore, regarding that person, the Buddha does not speak of a conviction in the Dhamma, but something special is said there: yassa saddhÄmattaį¹ hoti pemamattaį¹ā"who has a mere degree of faith, a mere degree of love" toward the TathÄgata. They have faith and love toward the TathÄgata. Now we can think of cases like Ven. Vakkali, whom you have heard of. Due to a highly developed faculty of faith (saddhindriya), perhaps from associating with Buddhas in past saį¹sÄric lives, they have without any doubt a deep faith and love toward the TathÄgata. That is why they are called SaddhÄnusÄrÄ«. Thus, the DhammÄnusÄrÄ« individual has the Dhamma convinced to some extent. The SaddhÄnusÄrÄ« individual does not even have that, but they have faith and love toward the TathÄgata. In addition to that, just like the former individual, they also have the five faculties established: faith (saddhÄ), energy (viriya), mindfulness (sati), concentration (samÄdhi), and wisdom (paƱƱÄ). They possess that qualification as well. Now you merit-seeking devotees have some understanding of these two.
Next, if anyone wishes to find a good Sutta to learn more about these two, there is a section of teachings in the Saį¹yutta NikÄya called the Okkantika Saį¹yuttaāa word of the Buddha, a Buddha-discourse. Okkantika is a word that carries the meaning of "entering into" or "descending into." Indeed, it is in that Okkantika Saį¹yutta that these two are specifically spoken of. In that Okkantika Saį¹yutta, the Buddha declares as follows: "Monks, the eye is impermanent (inconstant), subject to change, subject to becoming otherwise." The words used are aniccaį¹, vipariį¹Ämi, and aƱƱathÄbhÄvi. Just like the eye, all sixāincluding the ear, nose, tongue, body, and mind (mano)āare impermanent (inconstant), subject to change, subject to becoming otherwise. Regarding these declared facts, a person has, to a certain extent, gained a conviction. That is, the DhammÄnusÄrÄ« individual has not yet realized them through direct knowledge and vision (ƱÄį¹adassana). Yet, by directing the mind to them, they have become convinced to a certain degree: "This is indeed so." PaƱƱÄya mattaso nijjhÄnaį¹ khamantiāthey have accepted it through wisdom to a certain measure. Thus, something is declared there regarding that DhammÄnusÄrÄ« individual. Along with that, several other details are mentioned to identify that individual. Regarding that person, the words okkanto sammatta-niyÄmaį¹ are used. Then the Buddha declares that, in addition to the aforementioned qualification, this person:
The meaning of okkanto sammatta-niyÄmaį¹, dear devotees, is: sammatta means correctness or rightness. You devotees know the word sammÄ. Sammatta means the state of being correct or right. Therefore, they have entered the path of certainty, which is correctness. When the mind has entered this certainty of correctness, it does not turn back to the wrong side again. There are two states: micchatta and sammatta. Micchatta is the state of wrongness, while sammatta is the state of rightness. Thus, this DhammÄnusÄrÄ« individual has entered into the certainty called sammatta, having arrived at the correct path, the right way. Alongside that, it is said: sappurisabhÅ«miį¹ okkantoāthe DhammÄnusÄrÄ« individual has entered the plane of the virtuous (sappurisa). Devotees, the terms sappurisa (virtuous) and asappurisa (non-virtuous) are not used in the Dhamma merely in their worldly social meanings. The word sappurisa is applied to individuals. In the Sappurisa Sutta of the Majjhima NikÄya and other texts, it is applied to the noble (ariya) individual. The true sappurisa is that personāthe noble individual. Therefore, sappurisabhÅ«miį¹ okkanto means that this DhammÄnusÄrÄ« individual has also entered the plane of the noble ones. Next, another qualification is mentioned: vÄ«tivatto puthujjanabhÅ«miį¹āthey have transcended the plane of the ordinary worldling (puthujjana), going beyond the worldling's plane. Next, another thing is said: abhabbo taį¹ kammaį¹ kÄtuį¹ yaį¹ kammaį¹ karitvÄ nirayaį¹ vÄ tiracchÄnayoniį¹ vÄ pettivisayaį¹ vÄ... That means this DhammÄnusÄrÄ« individual is incapable of performing any unwholesome karma (kamma) that would cause rebirth in hell, the animal realm, or the ghost realm. They cannot do it. That is what abhabba (incapable) means. This too is a massive qualification. Now, we cannot say this about any one of you devoteesāthat you are incapable of doing so. This is the Buddha's word. The word abhabba is a special word. It means they can never do it again. And finally, the most special point is shown: that DhammÄnusÄrÄ« individual will not pass away without realizing the fruit of Stream-Entry (sotÄpattiphala). They will not die without realizing the fruit of Stream-Entry. Therefore, if by any chance the DhammÄnusÄrÄ« individual fails to become a Stream-Enterer beforehand, at the very last moment, before death, they will definitely become a Stream-Enterer. This is the word of the Buddha. That is why you merit-seeking devotees have now understood something about the DhammÄnusÄrÄ« individual.
Explaining the SaddhÄnusÄrÄ« individual is easy now, because in addition to the other points, it is also mentioned here. The SaddhÄnusÄrÄ« individual does not have those insights regarding impermanence (inconstancy) to that extent; they have not even gained a slight conviction in that way. But they possess faith and love. Now, whatever we mentioned as the special qualifications of the DhammÄnusÄrÄ« individual, all of those are possessed by the SaddhÄnusÄrÄ« individual as well. What are they? Having entered the certainty of correctness, having entered the plane of the virtuous, having transcended the plane of the ordinary worldling, they are incapable of performing any karma that would lead to rebirth in states of misery such as hell, the animal realm, or the ghost realm. Next, they will definitely attain the fruit of Stream-Entry before death. Thus, for you devotees who previously knew only of the four types of noble disciples, there is this kind of refuge in the Dispensation. Therefore, it is not just those four. Indeed, if one walks the path of the Dhamma correctly as introduced by the Buddha with genuine faith, then at the very least, like that newborn calf crossing over under its mother's protection, they too can cross over. The special thing is that before death, according to the Buddha's word, even when facing the death-sensation (moraį¹a vedanÄva / pain of death), they will practice insight (vipassanÄ) and become Stream-Enterers. That is what is declared there.
From there, let us proceed. You devotees have heard that on a day like today, in the Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta, the Buddha introduced this Noble Eightfold Path as the Middle Path. I believe you all know this. If we briefly consider at this moment what the Middle Path is: you devotees have heard of the two extremes that existed in the world, namely kÄmasukhallikÄnuyoga (devotion to sensual pleasure) and attakilamathÄnuyoga (devotion to self-mortification). Devotion to sensual pleasure can be understood as living a loose life, eating and drinking and enjoying the fivefold sensual pleasures without any belief in a next world, and without a correct understanding of this world. Devotion to self-mortification means needlessly torturing the body in order to save the soul, believing that NibbÄna can be realized through that aloneāthus having no understanding of the further shore. Both of those groups continue endlessly in saį¹sÄra. That is why the Middle Path discovered by the Buddhaāwhich He identified as the Middle Pathāis indeed the Noble Eightfold Path itself, which is secure. Such is the declaration.
Even if we do not discuss that Sutta at length: to convey the meaning, among whatever beings there areāfootless, two-footed, four-footed, many-footed, with form, formless, percipient, non-percipient, neither percipient nor non-percipientāthe TathÄgata is declared supreme. If anyone places faith in the TathÄgata, they have placed faith in the supreme being in the world. Next, it says finally: ye buddhe pasannÄ, agge te pasannÄ; agge kho pana pasannÄnaį¹, aggo vipÄko hotiā"Those who have confidence in the Buddha have confidence in the supreme; and for those with confidence in the supreme, supreme is the result." If someone has aroused faith in the TathÄgata Fully Self-Awakened One, they have aroused it toward the supreme being in the world. Therefore, that speaks of its benefits. They do not go to those extremes mentioned.
So, to speak further, first we must now discuss some deeper matters regarding the Noble Eightfold Path. You devotees might have heard of a Sutta called the AggappasÄda Sutta. The Buddha has preached the AggappasÄda Sutta in a way that deeply touches a faithful person, speaking about Himself. Since we are speaking of faith here, we have mentioned this on certain occasions. This discourse is such a powerful declaration: YÄvatÄ sattÄ apadÄ vÄ dvipadÄ vÄ catuppadÄ vÄ, bahuppadÄ vÄ, rÅ«pino vÄ, arÅ«pino vÄ, saƱƱino vÄ, asaƱƱino vÄ, nevasaƱƱinÄsaƱƱino vÄ, tathÄgato tesaį¹ aggamakkhÄyati, arahaį¹ sammÄsambuddho... "To whatever extent there are beingsāfootless, two-footed, four-footed, many-footed, with form, formless, percipient, non-percipient, neither-percipient-nor-non-percipientāthe TathÄgata is declared supreme among them, the Worthy One, the Fully Self-Awakened One." The benefits of gaining faith in the supreme person are likewise supreme. In the same way, the Sutta speaks of the Dhamma. Let us bring out the portion regarding the Dhamma here, as a deep point is mentioned: YÄvatÄ, bhikkhave, dhammÄ saį¹ khatÄ... "Monks, to whatever extent there are Preparations (saį¹ khÄra)..." Dear devotees, saį¹ khata (prepared/conditioned) means things that are constructed out of causes and conditions. Everything in the world is like thatāsomething constructed out of causes and conditions. Asaį¹ khata (the Unprepared/Unconditioned (asaį¹ khata)) refers to NibbÄna, in the sense of not being constructed out of causes and conditions. There are these two: saį¹ khata and asaį¹ khata. Among all conditioned things (saį¹ khata): yÄvatÄ, bhikkhave, dhammÄ saį¹ khatÄ, ariyo aį¹į¹haį¹ giko maggo tesaį¹ aggamakkhÄyatiāof all conditioned things, the Noble Eightfold Path is declared supreme. Having said that, it continues in the same way: Ye kho pana ariye magge pasannÄ, agge te pasannÄ; agge kho pana pasannÄnaį¹, aggo vipÄko hoti... Therefore, if one establishes confidence in the Noble Eightfold Path, that confidence yields the supreme result and benefit.
Why do we highlight this here? Because the Noble Eightfold Path is conditioned (saį¹ khata). This is a great wonder: through something conditioned (saį¹ khata), one proceeds toward the Unconditioned (asaį¹ khata). A logician of today might argue: "How can one go from the conditioned to the Unconditioned?" That is precisely where the genius of the Buddha lies! Utilizing the conditioned, the Middle Pathājust as that cowherd understood this bank and the further bank, and crossed over one group first with wisdom at the proper ford, and then through the faith generated by that, crossed the second group with a specific examination, finally crossing the entire herd down to the newborn calf born that very day. In the same way, we must understand that the Buddha crossed beings over through this Noble Eightfold Path.
Next, let us turn to another aspect. You devotees have heard so much about the Noble Eightfold Path and its eight factors. But many have not even reflected on why it is called a single unit, the "Noble Path" (ariyo maggo). All these eight factors form a single unit. Maggoāthe path is actually the Right Concentration (sammÄ-samÄdhi) that comes at the end. Right Concentration is the actual path. To explain this, we must point out that the Eightfold Path has both a mundane (lokiya) and a supramundane (lokuttara) aspect. There is a profound Sutta discourse in the Majjhima NikÄya that reveals this, named the MahÄcattÄrÄ«saka Sutta. Drawing from that MahÄcattÄrÄ«saka Sutta, let us proceed forward from there. In this MahÄcattÄrÄ«saka Sutta, the Buddha declares: "Monks, I shall expound to you Noble Right Concentration (ariya sammÄ-samÄdhi) with its vital conditions (saupanisaį¹) and its requisites (saparihÄraį¹)." You devotees know what parikkhÄra (requisites) meansārequisites offered to the Sangha are things that support life, things relevant to it. In the same way, the Buddha delivered this discourse saying, "I shall expound to you Noble Right Concentration with its supporting conditions (saupanisaį¹) and its requisites (saparihÄraį¹)." Through this, the Buddha directly shows that the first seven factors stand as requisites for Right Concentration. The seven factorsāRight View (sammÄ-diį¹į¹hi), Right Intention (sammÄ-saį¹ kappa), Right Speech (sammÄ-vÄcÄ), Right Action (sammÄ-kammanta), Right Livelihood (sammÄ-ÄjÄ«va), Right Effort (sammÄ-vÄyÄma), and Right Mindfulness (sammÄ-sati)āare required for establishing Right Concentration. This is a very deep matter. Given the time we have, let us mention this at least to generate interest, as it is highly relevant and important, especially since this aspect is barely considered in this day and age.
Thus, in speaking of Noble Right Concentration, the Buddha repeatedly utters a highly astonishing sentence that highlights the importance of Right View (sammÄ-diį¹į¹hi): "Monks, therein Right View comes first (tatra, bhikkhave, sammÄ-diį¹į¹hi pubbaį¹ gamÄ)." He constantly reminds us: Right View comes first, Right View comes first. Many people raise the question of why it is placed at the front. Right View comes first. What is the reason for this? Now, consider this: even to acquire Right View, a form of Right View is required! Sometimes we have to state things that seem like riddles: even to develop Right View, one needs Right View. What is the reason? The Buddha explains it in this way: Right View is the forerunner because, before acquiring Right View, one must recognize Wrong View (micchÄ-diį¹į¹hi) as Wrong View. For that too, Right View is required! Thus, in defining Right View, that is how the Buddha shows why Right View is the forerunner: one understands Wrong View as Wrong View, and one understands Right View as Right View.
Then, He shows something furtherāfrom here onward, the path becomes extraordinary. At this point, the Buddha declares Right View in a manner not found in other places: "Monks, I say Right View is twofold (sammÄ-diį¹į¹hiį¹ pahaį¹, bhikkhave, dvayaį¹ vadÄmi)." What is this twofold nature? He shows the two types next: "Monks, there is a Right View that is accompanied by taints (sÄsavÄ), siding with merit (puƱƱabhÄgiyÄ), ripening in the acquisitions (upadhivepakkÄ)." "Acquisitions" (upadhi) refers to worldly resources and possessions that support one in saį¹sÄra. There is a Right View that yields these; that is mundane Right View. "And there is, monks, a Right View that is Noble (ariyÄ), taintless (anÄsavÄ), supramundane (lokuttarÄ), which has become a factor of the supramundane path." Those are the two.
Out of these two, many people only know or have heard of the ten-point Right View. Perhaps you devotees have heard the oppositeāthe ten claims made by those with Wrong View about the world. In brief, they say: "There is no giving, no sacrifice, no offering; there is no fruit or result of good and bad actions; there is no this world, no next world; there is no mother, no father; there are no spontaneously born beings; there are no ascetics and brahmins who have correctly understood this world." This ten-point doctrine of "there is not" is called Wrong View. To all ten, the Buddha says "there is." That is mundane Right View: there are benefits and results of giving; there are results of wholesome and unwholesome actions; there are results of supporting parents; there are spontaneously born beings in this world; and there are ascetics and brahmins who explain this world and the next. This "is" perception replaces the "is-not" perceptionāasserting "there is" for what the others denied. That is the Middle Path. Those who make the "is-not" claims go to hell. If they say "there are no such things, let us eat, drink, and perish," they go to hell. At that level, the Buddha expounded this mundane Right View, which helps one avoid misery and attain happy states. Yet, one does not cross over from saį¹sÄra through this alone. That crossing over is achieved through the second type of Right View.
The Buddha accepts the former as sÄsavÄāthat Right View is accompanied by taints, yet it is puƱƱabhÄgiyÄ (siding with merit). It leans toward merit. Unlike the other group that leans toward demerit with Wrong View, this leans toward merit, toward the side of goodness. It also yields acquisitions as results (upadhivepakkÄ) in saį¹sÄra, bringing good rebirths. That much is there, and it is good for that purpose. But one must also be liberated from saį¹sÄra, must one not?
Now, that is achieved through supramundane Right View. What is described there is an extraordinary thing. That Noble, taintless (ariyÄ anÄsavÄ) Right View arises in that supramundane path-moment. Within an extremely brief moment, an incredibly wondrous thing occurs: at a certain point, all eight factors align and arise simultaneously in a single mind-moment to cross over. It is a highly wondrous event, about which various controversies exist. In that moment, Right View is described not through the ten mundane items, but as wisdom (paƱƱÄ), investigation of states (dhamma-vicaya), and so forth, relevant to that state. In that moment, Right View manifests in the form of investigation of states (dhamma-vicaya), wisdom (paƱƱÄ), and the faculty of wisdom (paƱƱindriya). That is supramundane Right View.
Similarly, we may not be able to describe each factor in detail due to time constraints. But keep this in mind: the Buddha shows that while you devotees may have heard to some extent about Right View, Right Intention, and so onāand can read about them in booksāhere, in the supramundane path, each of these is defined in a unique way. In that path-moment, they manifest in an extraordinary form. Right Intention does not manifest merely as ordinary thoughts (vitakka). It is not like how people think in the world. Even in terms of Wrong Intention (micchÄ-saį¹ kappa), Right View is required to recognize Wrong Intention as wrong, and Right Intention as right. First, Right View must lead. Next, while in the ordinary world, the three intentionsāintention of renunciation (nekkhamma), non-ill will (avyÄpÄda), and non-cruelty (avihiį¹sÄ)āare called Right Intention, in the supramundane state, it is the application and directing of the mind (takko vitakko) toward concentration; that mental power of directing is what is called Right Intention (sammÄ-saį¹ kappa).
Furthermore, what must be specifically noted is that Right Speech (sammÄ-vÄcÄ), Right Action (sammÄ-kammanta), and Right Livelihood (sammÄ-ÄjÄ«va) do not manifest in the supramundane path-moment as they do in ordinary situations. One has already abstained from those wrong behaviors beforehand. When that moment arises, the abstinence is already complete. Therefore, they manifest as abstinences (virati). There is no special effort to abstain in that moment; the abstinence is already established. Thus, one is detached from those three.
In this manner, next, He reveals something highly wondrous. In the supramundane state, protection is provided to that mind in three ways by the three factors: Right View, Right Effort, and Right Mindfulness. In that supramundane stateāthat is, when path-knowledge (magga-ƱÄį¹a) arisesāthey perform a special function, a special task. The words the Buddha uses for their action toward that mind are anuparidhÄvanti and anuparivattanti. AnuparidhÄvanti means they run along in association with it; anuparivattanti means they revolve in association with it. Thus, this supramundane path-momentāthe journey of using the conditioned (saį¹ khata) to reach the Unconditioned (asaį¹ khata)āis a highly wondrous and miraculous event. In it, protection is provided to that mind. Right View leads, Right Effort supports from behind by giving a push and providing security, and Right Mindfulness remains close at hand to assist.
Even if it is not an orthodox simile from the texts, we have on some occasion expressed this in a way that touches your hearts. Today, when prominent politicians or VIPs travel, there is no need to explaināone group of security personnel moves ahead, another group follows behind to protect them from danger, and another group stays right next to them. It is exactly like that. Just as the great figures of the world travel with such security, the two beautiful words anuparidhÄvanti and anuparivattanti appear there to describe the retinue that accompanies Noble Right Concentration as it performs its immense, powerful task. These three factorsāRight View, Right Effort, and Right Mindfulnessāprovide security during the supramundane path-moment. Similarly, with the other three factors we mentioned earlier, in daily life one constantly makes an effort to abandon Wrong Speech and practice Right Speech. In that way, it is merely a training (sikkhÄ). That training is practiced over a long time. When that training is perfected, in that moment it is described as Ärati (avoiding), virati (abstinence), and pativirati (refraining)āthat person has distanced themselves far from it. This abstinence (virati) itself becomes a protection for Noble Right Concentration.
The internal, inner nature of these eight factors is truly wondrous and miraculous. We simply go on repeating "eight," but through these eight, on one hand, a being is prevented from falling into states of misery and is directed toward happy realms by that mundane Right View accompanied by taints (sÄsava). Supramundane Right View performs an even more powerful task: transcending this worldliness in the state of path and fruit. To put it briefly, let us consider it this way: while practicing a concentration such as mindfulness of breathing (ÄnÄpÄnasati) as shown by the Buddha, if one also develops insight (vipassanÄ) into the Three Characteristics (anicca, dukkha, anattÄ), then by the time the factors of awakeningāspecifically, the thirty-seven aids to awakening (of which those five we mentioned are the spiritual faculties)āare perfected, it happens almost effortlessly. It occurs naturally, and at that point, there is a powerful disenchantment (nibbidÄ) toward the five aggregates (paƱcakkhandha). Through that disenchantment, one attains the supramundane state. One lets go of this bank and leaps to the other bank. In that moment, protection is provided to that Right Concentration. Devotees, it is about that Right Concentration that you have all heard in the Ratana Sutta:
Yaį¹ buddhaseį¹į¹ho parivaį¹į¹ayÄ« suciį¹,
samÄdhimÄnantarikaƱƱamÄhu,
samÄdhinÄ tena samo na vijjati...
"The pure concentration which the supreme Buddha praised, and which they call the 'immediate concentration' (concentration with immediate result)āno equal to that concentration is found." It is that immediate concentration (Änantarika-samÄdhi) that is spoken of there. The Änantarika-samÄdhi highly praised by the Buddha is indeed path-concentration (magga-samÄdhi). Immediately following that path-concentration, one realizes the fruit (phala). That is why it is called "immediate" (Änantarika).
It is mentioned in the commentaries that scholars of the past had various controversies regarding this. But to be brief due to time constraints: you devotees have heard of the eight noble individuals. If asked, you might immediately answer, "The one on the path of Stream-Entry, the one in its fruit," and so on. That is how people answer: the four paths and the four fruits. But, devotees, this is how it is mentioned in the Dhamma. The eight noble individuals are mentioned in several places, not just one, as follows: sotÄpanno, sotÄpattiphala-sacchikiriyÄya paį¹ipanno (one practicing for the realization of the fruit of Stream-Entry), sakadÄgÄmÄ«, sakadÄgÄmiphala-sacchikiriyÄya paį¹ipanno, anÄgÄmÄ«, anÄgÄmiphala-sacchikiriyÄya paį¹ipanno, and so on. That is how the eight are spoken of. Thus, what must be specially noted here is that although we use the words magga (path) and paį¹ipadÄ (practice/way) as synonyms, there is a certain difference between them. One enters the path by fulfilling a course of practice (paį¹ipadÄ); it is within that course of practice. Now this aligns. We began this sermon, or rather highlighted as a special point, the two individuals: DhammÄnusÄrÄ« and SaddhÄnusÄrÄ«. It is often said of these two that they are "on the path of Stream-Entry" (sotÄpatti-magga). What we must say is that they are those who are in the course of practice (paį¹ipadÄ) leading to that supramundane path. It was mentioned, was it not: sotÄpanno, sotÄpattiphala-sacchikiriyÄya paį¹ipanno. If it could be said briefly, the Buddha would have said directly "those on the path of Stream-Entry." Since the path of Stream-Entry is momentary, how can it apply to all eight? If the mind-moment is just one flash, how can gifts be given to all eight? Now here, we showed that those two individuals, the DhammÄnusÄrÄ« and SaddhÄnusÄrÄ«, are in the category of sotÄpattiphala-sacchikiriyÄya paį¹ipanno (practicing for the realization of the fruit of Stream-Entry). It is clearly visible, is it not? The Buddha declared that before death, these two will somehow reach the fruit of Stream-Entry. Therefore, they too are noble (ariya) individuals. They have entered the plane of the virtuous, having transcended the state of the ordinary worldling. The problem lies right there. Therefore, in accordance with the Dhamma and the Suttas, we must apply this to the course of practice (paį¹ipadÄ). Those who have entered the practice that leads to entering the path of Stream-Entry are called paį¹ipanna (practitioners). Those who have entered that practice are the SaddhÄnusÄrÄ« and DhammÄnusÄrÄ«. It is not the path of Stream-Entry itselfāif the path of Stream-Entry arises, the fruit follows directly, immediately. That is what "immediate" (Änantarika) means. Thus, the supramundane path is different. What is spoken of here is the course of practice (paį¹ipadÄ). Hence, there is a verse in the Aį¹ guttara NikÄya that makes this very clear:
paį¹ipannÄ cattÄro ca, phale į¹hitÄ...
esa saį¹ gho ujubhÅ«to, paƱƱÄ-sÄ«la-samÄhito
"Four practicing and four established in the fruit, this is the upright Sangha, composed of wisdom, virtue, and concentration." Paį¹ipannÄāit could have said maggaį¹į¹hÄ (established in the path) there. But it does not. You devotees have heard the word maggastha (on the path). There is no mention of maggastha here; it is paį¹ipanna. "Four practicing (paį¹ipannÄ) and four established in the fruit (phale į¹hitÄ)"āthere are the eight. The four who have entered the practice (paį¹ipadÄ) and the four established in the fruit. "This is the upright Sangha" (esa saį¹ gho ujubhÅ«to). These are described as the eight upright noble individuals, "endowed with wisdom, virtue, and concentration" (paƱƱÄ-sÄ«la-samÄhito). The eight shown in this verse are what we specifically mentioned. Although we generally treat "path" (magga) and "practice" (paį¹ipadÄ) as synonymous, there is a distinction here. Therefore, in identifying and introducing noble individuals, we must be careful: it is not "established in the path" (maggaį¹į¹ha) that is meant, but rather having entered the practice (paį¹ipadÄ) for realizing the fruit of Stream-Entry. This would need to be explained in more detail; it is not simple.
Who are the eight? The Stream-Enterer; the individual who has entered the practice for realizing the fruit of Stream-Entry; the Once-Returner; the individual who has entered the practice for realizing the fruit of Once-Return. We spoke specifically of the one who has attained the fruit of Stream-Entry. You devotees can deduce the rest. Suppose someone has attained the fruit of Stream-Entry. If they do not fall into negligence as a negligent disciple (sekha), but continue to work further, walking that path of knowledge, then from that point on, the practice they undertake from being a Stream-Enterer until they become a Once-Returner is called sakadÄgÄmiphala-sacchikiriyÄya paį¹ipannoāstriving to reach the fruit of Once-Return. One can understand it in that way, up to the last one: the Arahant, and arahattÄya paį¹ipannoāthe Arahant, and the individual practicing for the realization of Arhatship.
Thus, what we have expounded to you devotees is deep. If deep Dhamma is unnecessarily simplified and presented as shallow, it would lead to the destruction of the Dhamma. Without simplifying it in that manner, but presenting the Dhamma as Dhamma, we have explained this Middle Path as set forth by the Buddha to some extent within one hour to you devotees on this valuable day. This aspect of the Dispensation is now largely forgotten. Therefore, you devotees have kept virtue (sÄ«la) today on this valuable day to the best of your ability. Many lay devotees who come to us now say: "I do not want to be born in saį¹sÄra anymore. I must go somewhere and attain the paths and fruits as quickly as possible. I want to go somewhere and ordain." Everyone speaks in this way. Thus, we presented this to help those people, so that they may reflect. Even if one cannot attain the fruit of Stream-Entry, this is a great consolation. Let us at least strive to be like that calf urged on by its mother's protective lowing. That is what we have to say to you devotees.
Thus, through the virtue kept today, the meditation practiced, and this insight-oriented Dhamma sermon heard, may you devotees be able to bring your learning and meditation to fruition as quickly as possible, realize those noble states mentioned, and cross over the entire wilderness of saį¹sÄra, facilitating this crossing from this shore to the other shore. In the past, "going from this shore to the other shore" did not mean traveling abroad; it meant crossing over this ocean of saį¹sÄra. May you devotees receive the necessary strength, power, and massive energy for that purpose. May your learning and meditation quickly bear fruit, and may you gain the ability to reach that peace of NibbÄna. From the AvÄ«ci hell to the Akaniį¹į¹ha heaven, if there be any who wish to rejoice in the merits of this Dhamma preaching and Dhamma hearing, may they, through that rejoicing, realize the supreme, great, deathless NibbÄna by means of their aspired-for enlightenment (bodhi). May you devotees also receive the strength and power to realize that supreme, great, deathless NibbÄna very soon. With that aspiration, let us recite these verses.
āEttÄvatÄ ca amhehi.........ā